Border Collie vs Shiba Inu: Which Breed Is Right For You?

This post contains affiliate links.

Deciding which breed of dog to bring into your home is an important choice that requires careful consideration. Two popular breeds that often come up in this debate are the Border Collie and the Shiba Inu. Both breeds have their unique qualities, characteristics, and needs, making it essential to assess which breed is the right fit for you and your lifestyle.

Breed Comparison Table

BREED	Border Collie	Shiba Inu
Hypoallergenic?	No	No
Restricted Breed?	No	No
Coat Type	Double coat	Double coat
Grooming Needs	Regular brushing, occasional hand stripping	Regular brushing, occasional hand stripping
Male Height	18-22 inches	17-19 inches
Male Weight	30-45 pounds	23-27 pounds
Female Height	17-21 inches	16-18 inches
Female Weight	25-35 pounds	20-24 pounds
Temperament	Intelligent, energetic, active, loyal	Independent, loyal, protective, reserved
Energy Level	4/5	4/5
Exercise Needs	4/5	3/5
Trainability	5/5	3/5
Good For Novice Owners	3/5	4/5
Amount Of Shedding	3/5	4/5
Easy To Groom	4/5	4/5
Prey Drive	5/5	3/5
General Health	1/5	3/5
Tolerates Being Alone	1/5	5/5
Tolerates Cold Weather	2/5	4/5
Affectionate With Family	5/5	4/5
Kid-Friendly	5/5	3/5
Dog Friendly	5/5	3/5
Friendly Toward Strangers	5/5	3/5
Tolerates Hot Weather	4/5	3/5
Intelligence	4/5	4/5
Lifespan	10 to 15 years	12 to 16 years
Popularity	#30	#42
Price	$800 – $2,000	$1,000 – 2,500

About Shiba Inus

Shiba Inus, also known as “little foxes,” are a small and sturdy breed that originated in Japan. Their adorable appearance is highlighted by their curly tails and expressive almond-shaped eyes.

Shibas have a proud posture that exudes confidence and a muscular build, standing at around 13.5 to 16.5 inches tall at the shoulder and weighing between 17 to 23 pounds. They have a double coat that provides excellent protection against cold weather conditions and comes in various colors such as red, sesame, black and tan, or cream.

Shiba Inus require regular brushing to maintain their low-maintenance fur and are known for being independent thinkers with a curious nature.

About Border Collie

The Border Collie is a highly intelligent and energetic herding breed originating from the border region between England and Scotland. They are versatile working dogs with a well-proportioned body, a beautiful variety of coat types and colors, and generally considered a healthy breed.

Their temperament is described as highly intelligent and eager to please, making them exceptional herding dogs as well as successful participants in agility trials or obedience competitions. Mental stimulation through activities like puzzle toys or interactive games is crucial to their overall happiness and well-being.

Border Collie Vs Shiba Inu: Size and Weight

Border Collies and Shiba Inus differ in size and weight. Border Collies are medium-sized dogs, with males standing between 19 to 22 inches at the shoulder and weighing around 30 to 45 pounds.

Females are about 18 to 21 inches tall and weigh around 27 to 42 pounds. In contrast, Shiba Inus are small dogs, with males typically standing at 14.5 to 16.5 inches and weighing approximately 23 pounds.

Females are slightly smaller, measuring around 13.5 to 15.5 inches tall and weighing around 17 pounds. Despite their size differences, both breeds have an elegant stature. Consider the size variations when choosing a breed that fits your lifestyle.

Border Collie Vs Shiba Inu: Coat Type

Border Collies and Shiba Inus have different coat types. Border Collies have a dense, straight outer coat and a soft, insulating undercoat that helps regulate temperature. Shiba Inus have a stiff, straight outer coat and a short, soft undercoat that sheds less. Grooming requirements vary between these breeds.

Are Either Breed Hypoallergenic?

Individuals with allergies often seek hypoallergenic dog breeds. However, Border Collies and Shiba Inus are not hypoallergenic due to their moderately shedding double coats.

These breeds may not be suitable for individuals with severe allergies. Border Collies have a dense, weather-resistant coat that requires grooming during seasonal changes while Shiba Inus have a thick double coat that sheds heavily twice a year.

Although mild allergy sufferers may be able to tolerate these breeds, allergy-reducing practices and allergist consultation are necessary for severe cases.

Grooming Needs

When it comes to grooming, Border Collies and Shiba Inus have different needs. Border Collies require regular brushing to maintain their dense double coat, while paying attention to their floppy ears to prevent infections.

Shiba Inus have a more manageable grooming routine, but still require regular brushing during shedding seasons. Both breeds require bathing only when necessary, while maintaining good hygiene practices like nail trimming and dental care are essential for any pet.

Border Collie Vs Shiba Inu: Colors

Border Collies and Shiba Inus have a wide range of coat colors. Border Collies can have black and white, tri-color, sable, and even brindle coats.

Shiba Inus typically come in four primary colors: red, sesame, black and tan, and cream. These base colors play a significant role in defining each dog’s personality traits.

Border Collie Vs Shiba Inu: Diet

When choosing a diet for your Border Collie or Shiba Inu, consider their nutritional needs and preferences. Both breeds require high-quality dog food rich in protein, but there are slight differences in their dietary requirements.

Border Collies need a well-balanced diet to support their active lifestyle and thrive on a high-protein diet with essential fatty acids, real meat, and complex carbohydrates. Shiba Inus, on the other hand, benefit from a high-protein diet but may require slightly less quantity due to their smaller size and moderate activity levels.

They may also benefit from a grain-free option if they have allergies or sensitivities to certain ingredients. Regardless of breed, it’s crucial not to overfeed your dog as obesity can lead to various health problems.

Consult your veterinarian to ensure that you’re providing them with the best diet based on their unique nutritional requirements.

Border Collie Vs Shiba Inu: Health Problems

Border Collies and Shiba Inus both have unique health concerns. Border Collies can experience hip dysplasia and epilepsy, while Shiba Inus may face patellar luxation and allergies. Regular exercise and veterinary check-ups are important for both breeds.

Border Collie Vs Shiba Inu: Temperament

Border Collies and Shiba Inus have distinct temperaments. Border Collies are affectionate and highly trainable, while Shiba Inus are independent and assertive. Both breeds require early socialization and training to mitigate potential issues.

When deciding between these two breeds, consider your lifestyle and ability to provide necessary training and socialization.

Which Breed Is More Playful?

Both Border Collies and Shiba Inus have their own unique charm when it comes to playfulness. Border Collies are known for their boundless energy, agility, and athleticism, excelling in activities like frisbee and flyball.

Shiba Inus, on the other hand, possess a mischievous streak that adds an extra dose of playfulness to their personality and love engaging in interactive games that challenge their intelligence.

Are Border Collies Good Family Dogs?

When considering a Border Collie as a family pet, it’s important to understand their high energy levels and intense herding instincts. Providing ample exercise, mental challenges, and socialization with young children can make them wonderful companions for active families.

Border Collie Vs Shiba Inu: Trainability

Both Border Collies and Shiba Inus have unique trainability traits. Border Collies are highly intelligent, eager to please, and excel in obedience training. Shiba Inus are independent thinkers and may be more stubborn, requiring patience and consistency in training.

Both breeds respond best to positive reinforcement methods and early socialization for well-rounded development.

Are Border Collies or Shiba Inus Harder to Train?

Border Collies and Shiba Inus have unique traits that make their training slightly challenging. Border Collies are intelligent and eager to learn, but require mental stimulation to prevent boredom.

Shiba Inus are independent thinkers that may require more effort to grasp commands, so positive reinforcement techniques combined with firm consistency are necessary. Both breeds benefit from early socialization and obedience classes.

Border Collie Vs Shiba Inu: Life Expectancy

Border Collies have a slightly longer lifespan compared to Shiba Inus, with a range of 12 to 15 years versus 10 to 14 years. However, these figures are just averages and individual dogs may vary. Both breeds can be prone to certain health conditions, but with proper care, they can thrive and live happy lives.

Border Collie Vs Shiba Inu: Prey Drive

Border Collies have a strong herding instinct and may exhibit a high prey drive due to their history of working closely with livestock. Socialization is key to prevent chasing behavior towards smaller animals.

Shiba Inus were originally bred for hunting small game and may still have a moderate prey drive. Basic commands and mentally stimulating activities can help manage prey drive in both breeds.

Are Border Collies or Shibas Better With Other Pets?

While Border Collies have a strong herding instinct that may cause them to chase smaller animals, proper training and socialization can help them coexist peacefully with other pets.

Shiba Inus are more independent but can still get along with other pets if introduced correctly. Early socialization is key for both breeds, and it’s important to remember that each dog is unique and may have different interactions with other pets.

Are Border Collies or Shibas Better With Kids?

Border Collies are known for being excellent with children due to their natural herding instincts and loyalty to their owners. In contrast, Shiba Inus can have an independent nature that may make it challenging for them to adjust to a household with kids, but early socialization and training can help them become more comfortable.

Border Collie Vs Shiba Inu: Intelligence

Border Collies and Shiba Inus are both intelligent dog breeds, but showcase their intelligence in different ways. Border Collies are highly trainable and excel in herding and agility, while Shiba Inus have a unique intelligence rooted in their independent nature and cunning problem-solving skills.

Training methods should be tailored to each breed’s learning style and personality.

Border Collie Vs Shiba Inu: Popularity

Both the Border Collie and Shiba Inu have loyal fan bases. The Border Collie is known for its herding abilities and intelligence, consistently ranking high on the American Kennel Club’s list of most registered breeds.

The Shiba Inu has gained popularity due to its fox-like appearance and charming personality, as well as its manageable size.

Border Collie Vs. Shiba Inu: How Much Do They Cost?

When considering getting a new pet, it’s important to factor in the cost. Owning a pet comes with financial responsibilities, and both Border Collies and Shiba Inus have their own set of expenses.

Let’s take a closer look at the finances and explore the cost of these breeds. First, let’s talk about the initial purchase price. Border Collies are generally more expensive than Shiba Inus because of their popularity and versatility.

Border Collie puppies from reputable breeders typically cost between $800 – $2,000, while Shiba Inu puppies cost between $1,000 – 2,500. Prices vary based on location and lineage, but ongoing expenses like food, veterinary care, grooming, and supplies should also be considered.

When budgeting for your dog, consider their specific needs. Border Collies require more food due to their active nature, while Shiba Inus have smaller appetites.

Both breeds need quality nutrition for their athletic abilities, with Border Collies requiring $50-$70 per month and Shiba Inus requiring $40-$60 per month for high-quality dog food. Grooming costs differ, with Border Collies shedding more throughout the year.

It is important to brush both breeds regularly, but Border Collies may require more time. Consider buying grooming tools such as brushes and deshedding tools, which can cost around $20 to $40.

Veterinary care is also an expense to consider. Both breeds are generally healthy, but routine vaccinations, check-ups, and unforeseen medical issues can add up over time. It is recommended to set aside a minimum of $500 to $800 per year for veterinary expenses.

Additionally, don’t forget about other expenses such as toys, training classes, collars and leashes, beds, and crates.

It’s important to keep in mind that the price of these items may vary depending on your preferences and the quality you select. These are rough estimates, and the cost can be influenced by location, breeder reputation, quality of supplies purchased, and unforeseen circumstances.

Before bringing any of these wonderful breeds into your home, it’s critical to conduct thorough research on reputable breeders or consider adopting from a rescue organization.

Evaluating both the initial and ongoing expenses will help you determine which breed is best suited to your budget without sacrificing the care and well-being of your furry friend.

Conclusion: Should You Get a Border Collie or Shiba Inu?

When choosing between a Border Collie and Shiba Inu, consider your lifestyle, preferences, and commitment to caring for these breeds.

Border Collies are ideal for active individuals or families who enjoy outdoor activities and require mental stimulation, while Shiba Inus are better suited for those who value an independent yet affectionate companion.

Both breeds require consistent training and care, but can bring immense joy and companionship to your life.

Other Dog Breed Comparisons

Large Breeds

Medium Breeds

Small Breeds